THE INFALLIBILITY OF THE SUPREME COURT AND THE CHALLENGES OF DEMOCRATIC CONSOLIDATION IN NIGERIA, 1999 - 2019

Authors

  • Cinjel Nandes Dickson Federal University Wukari
  • Oboromeni Weinoh Federal University Lokoja

Keywords:

Supreme Court, Democratic consolidation, INEC, Nigeria, Political Participation

Abstract

The Supreme Court of Nigeria (SCN) is the highest appellate court in the country. The decision of the court and its actions are not only final but are seen as infallible and sacrosanct. The Supreme Court and its application in various electoral cases have generated mixed feelings and raised questions on the credibility of the Nigerian judiciary and its capability of ensuring sustainable democracy in the country. This study examines the infallibility status of the Supreme Court of Nigeria and the challenges of democratic consolidation in the country, from 1999 to 2019. The study is anchored on the doctrine of absolute political theory. The secondary data used in this study were drawn from documentary facts generated from an array of both published and unpublished materials such as textbooks, journals, magazines, newspapers, conference and seminar papers, internet materials, reports of electoral tribunals of the election, and many more. Primary data was generated using the interview method, which combines key informants’ interviews and focused group discussions. In interpreting the data, the relationship was established between the infallible status of the Supreme Court on electoral issues and its implication on Nigerian Democracy. Empirically, the study used a qualitative and historical method that is critical and analytical in providing descriptive and historical details. This was complemented by descriptive quantitative analysis. In doing that, the information gathered was summarized and processed through a statistical package for social science (SPSS). The study found that the infallibility of the Supreme Court verdicts on electoral issues has a significant effect on sustainable democracy in Nigeria. The study recommends among others that there is a need for radical reform and overhaul in the judiciary and judicial process, independence of INEC, and many others.

Author Biographies

Cinjel Nandes Dickson, Federal University Wukari

Cinjel Nandes Dickson is with the Department of Public Administration, Federal University Wukari

Oboromeni Weinoh, Federal University Lokoja

Oboromeni Weinoh are with the Department of Public Administration, Federal University Lokoja

Downloads

Published

2023-03-02

How to Cite

Dickson, C. N., & Weinoh, O. (2023). THE INFALLIBILITY OF THE SUPREME COURT AND THE CHALLENGES OF DEMOCRATIC CONSOLIDATION IN NIGERIA, 1999 - 2019. Arts and Social Science Research, 12(1), 26. Retrieved from https://fassjassr.com.ng/index.php/assr/article/view/55